Custom Sugar Cookies

All cookies are made to order and hand-decorated with royal icing. Pricing is based on the number of unique designs included — the more designs, the more time and color preparation required. Each cookie is individually packaged and sealed for freshness.

Custom orders requested within a 7-day window or during the peak holiday season may incur a rush fee. Rush fees are calculated based on the size and complexity of the order, with higher-volume orders subject to higher fees.

1 design — $54

2 designs — $60

3 designs — $68

4 designs — $75

5 designs — $82

Starting at $54/dozen

Order Form

Full payment is required upon invoicing to be added to the schedule. Invoices will be sent via email with Square.

All orders are free pick up (Flatbush or Gowanus). A fee will be added for delivery.